JOURNAL OF EDUCATION FOR LIBRARY
AND INFORMATION SCIENCE

 

Manuscript Evaluation

 

Please complete form and mail or fax to:
University of Arizona
School of Info. Resources and Library Science
1515 E. First Street
Tucson, AZ 85719
fax: 520-621-3279

Also available in PDF

Manuscript #:
Referee:
Date Due :










Evaluation:
5 = agree totally
4 = agree somewhat
3 = neutral or not applicable
2 = disagree somewhat
1 = disagree totally

 

 

The manuscript:

Adds new information or deepens understanding of a significant problem or issue
 5    4    3    2    1
Has a clearly stated thesis or hypothesis
 5    4    3    2    1
Uses appropriate research methods
5    4    3    2    1
Cites the relevant literature
5    4    3    2    1
Is organized logically
5    4    3    2    1
Is written well
5    4    3    2    1
Uses data and/or analysis to make a compelling argument
5    4    3    2    1


Please check one:

Publish with no further revision or only minor revisions as indicated below
Publish after revision to address key questions and concerns indicated below
Do not publish; indicate reason below

 

 

Comments (please attach additional sheet if necessary):

COPYRIGHT 2013 - ASSOCIATION FOR LIBRARY AND INFORMATION SCIENCE EDUCATION